mrhid6andClaude Opus 5
ff0caf5a90
Two deployments times three tiers, servers metered per month, console and SSO opted into individually. plans is re-keyed on (deployment, tier); every Paddle price ID moves out of plans into a new catalogue collection; a new entitlements collection holds desired beside granted, and a licence is only ever signed from granted. Spec 5's plan is revised rather than followed: it assumes one price per subscription and a metered plan has three or more. Nothing of it has shipped, so the revision costs a rewrite of an unstarted plan. Free stops being cloud-only by construction, which means the plan/instance deployment comparison in licensing.Issue no longer enforces it and checkFreeLimit has to count per deployment. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Vantage Licensing Programme — Spec Index
Build in this order. Specs 0a–5 were designed 2026-07-24; spec 6 on 2026-07-26.
| # | Spec | Plan | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0a | shared-module | plan | shipped |
| 0b | instance-rename | plan | shipped, migration verified on live |
| 1 | licensing-core | plan | shipped |
| 2 | instance-licensing | plan | shipped, no grandfathering — existing cloud instances are read-only until admin backfills |
| 3 | admin-backend | plan | shipped, verified end to end against scratch databases |
| 4 | admin-site | — | ready to start |
| 5 | paddle-billing | plan | ready to start, but revised by 7 — its "signup migration off sitesvc" section is superseded by 6, and its single-price-per-subscription assumption by 7 |
| 6 | cloud-instance-creation | — | ready to start |
| 7 | metered-licensing | — | designed; build before 5, whose plan it revises |
Specs 1 and 2 together give working licensing with licences cut by hand with
lkctl — no admin service needed. 4 and 5 can run in parallel once 3 lands.
7 lands before 5. It re-keys plans on (deployment, tier), moves every Paddle
price ID out of plans into a new catalogue collection, and adds the
entitlements collection that both a subscription and a licence are derived from
— all of which plan 5 builds on top of, so building 5 first would mean writing
its billing code twice.
The shape
Account (admin only)
├── Instance 1 cloud vantage.hostxtra.co.uk/<slug> licence auto-injected
├── Instance 2 cloud licence auto-injected
└── Instance 3 self-hosted customer's own deployment licence pasted by hand
The control plane knows only Instance. Accounts exist solely in the admin service, because a self-hosted instance has no row in the cloud database at all.
Decisions that everything else follows from
Licences are offline-verified signed blobs. ECDSA P-384 with SHA-256 via
github.com/hyperboloide/lk, public key compiled into the server, no phone-home
anywhere. This buys air-gapped self-hosting and means no Vantage instance ever
depends on the licensing service being up. It costs revocation: a licence is
valid until it expires whatever Paddle later says. Self Hosted is annual-only to
bound that window.
Every licence is bound to one instance UUID. Self-hosted customers link their UUID before the licence is signed, so there is no unbound licence and no claim protocol.
Expiry degrades, it does not break. Monitors keep executing, alerts keep firing, agents keep their keys, in-flight workflow runs finish. Mutations stop. Deletes and OS-update application stay open so a customer is never trapped over-limit or unpatched.
Tiers are data, not code. The server reads Limits and Features and never
branches on tier name. Tier contents live in the admin plans table and are
snapshotted into each issued licence, so editing a plan never rewrites history —
the same rule as workflow_runs.steps_snapshot.
Spec 7 replaces the three-tier table below with two deployments times three tiers, and makes the server count a metered quantity rather than a fixed allowance. See metered-licensing for the current grid. As shipped through spec 3, the table is:
| Free | Professional | Self Hosted | |
|---|---|---|---|
| deployment | cloud only | cloud | self-hosted |
| max servers | 3 | unlimited | unlimited |
| max secret groups | 1 | unlimited | unlimited |
| max channels | 1 | unlimited | unlimited |
| console | no | yes | yes |
| OIDC | no | yes | yes |
| term | monthly, £0 | monthly or annual | annual only |
Free is cloud-only by construction: it is only ever signed with
deployment: "cloud", and verification rejects a deployment mismatch. There is
no server-side flag to edit. One Free instance per account.
Spec 7 ends that construction-level guarantee — there is a self-hosted Free
plan, so plan.Deployment != inst.Deployment no longer implies it, and the Free
limit becomes one per account per deployment.
Existing cloud tenants are not grandfathered. The migration that would have
done it was removed before plan 2 shipped, so every existing cloud instance is
read-only until it is licensed by hand through the admin service: attach it to an
account with POST /api/staff/instances, then POST /api/staff/instances/:id/issue.
That flow is verified in plan 3, so it works today via the API and is the first
job the admin UI is used for.